Guided By Voices, Hold on Hope EP- Michelle Aguilar

REVIEW: Guided By Voices, Hold on Hope EP (TVT)

- Michelle Aguilar

Any Guided By Voices fans still bitter about Do the Collapse will be sorely disappointed if they think this was the EP to signal the band's journey back from their keyboard-dripping, Ric Ocasek-induced fugue of 1999. But then, these nine songs are certainly not more of the same either.

At first, this could easily seem like a calculated move by TVT to suck in the newer GBV fans with more oif that 80s New Wave fun that was so successful. And certainly, the first track, "Underground Initiations" is undeniably fuzzy, poppy and catchy in the same way as songs from that album. (Seriously, you'd have to be made of stone to hate this song) and the last song, "Hold on Hope" actually is from the 1999 album. But in other ways, it isn't. It's something in between the old and the new. While most of these songs were produced by Ocasek, the majority of them don't quite have the same wonderfully kitschy sheen he put onto the entirety of Do the Collapse_" The songs sound simpler, more forlorn, less like a blissful pop billyclub over your head. And yet, this EP is no Alien Lanes.

There's some interesting little experiments here, such as "A Crick Uphill," a number that almost verges into GBV's own take on country folk pop. With sweet vocals, a bass-driven melody and contagiously bright rhythm guitar, it's reminiscent of the Beatles' flirtations with the old-time Nashville pop on Help and Rubber Soul_" Then there's "Avalanche Aminos," the only co-written song (with Doug Gillard), which is based on electric guitar riff arpeggios that so stubbornly go nowhere for half the song. It actually works in a strange way, creating an unexpectedly satisfying tension. And besides, like any good GBV song, just as you start getting fed up with it, it's over. "Interest Position," with its fuzz tones and relentless rolling toms is closer to "Do The Collapse," territory. It's very respectably catchy and upbeat and eminently listenable.

Unfortunately, "Fly Into Ashes," doesn't fare quite as well, feeling a little bit soulless as it slogs through verse, verse, chorus instrumental, reprise, etc. etc. Still, impossibly obscure lyrics such as "artificial study guides will help you when you're ready boy" hold one's interest even through the slower moments. Ditto for "Idiot Princess," which is really way better than so much pop crap out there, yet in context, sounds like it wasn't quite compelling enough for Ocasek's unstoppable pop juggernaut.

Perhaps this is also what happened to "Do the Collapse," an instrumental track included on this EP but not on Sounding like a band that just finished setting up its instruments and meandering into an impromptu sound check, based on power chorsds that nobody can seem to do anything with until they just quit sheepishly.

There is one surprise nugget for the old stalwarts though. "Tropical Robots," is quiet, acoustic, extremely sad and pretty and like old-school GBV, it's over too damn quickly, just as it's getting good . It sounds like something from three albums back. And it reminds me anew why I had no problem when Do the Collapse came out last year and even cherished it. It meant Bob Pollard's beautiful pop songs got to stay around that much longer.


Issue Index
WestNet Home Page   |   Previous Page   |   Next Page