REVIEW: Tragically Hip, Phantom Power (Sire)
- Chris Hill
A friend asked me the other day, while listening to
Phantom Power, "Can they MAKE a bad album?". My answer - no,
they can't. Twelve songs form their most cohesive album
since '92's Fully Completely. Warm and personal, the disc is
replete with organic themes: growth, love, nature, maturity.
Gordon Downie's oblique, literate songwriting is a joy to
experience. "You said you didn't give a f*ck about hockey/and I
never saw someone say that before/you held my hand and we walked
home the long way/you were loosening my grip on Bobby Orr" (from
"Fireworks") - there's the burgeoning crush, the clash of man and
woman, all couched within a sports reference. Another song,
"Membership" uses the current of a river as a metaphor for
surrending the self to love and life.
Downie's singing swoops, soars, and stuttersteps
through the material, even trying a falsetto chorus during the
bouncy, acoustic "Thompson Girl". With their backing vocals,
guitarist Paul Langlois and bassist Gord Sinclair offer a
distinctive, welcome counterpoint.
Rounded out by drummer Johnny Fay and guitarist Rob Baker,
the Hip shuffle tempos from rock ("Save the Planet", "Poets") to
ballads ("Bobcaygeon", "The Rules") to somewhere in-between
("Chagrin Falls", "Emperor Penguin"). This album will please the
longtime fan and enchant the newcomer - what more to ask for?
The Hip also have one of the best Web presences around at
http://www.thehip.com . Check out their site and see how these
songs germinated and grew. Fascinating reading.